| As Pastimes Football Club |
| A Grade |
| 1920 |
| 1923 Pastimes 9.11 (65) defeated South Bunbury 6.7 (43) |
| 1924 Pastimes 10.7 (67) defeated South Bunbury 7.7 (49) |
| 1932 Pastimes 7.12 (54) defeated Railways 3.12 (30) |
| 1938 Pastimes 14.10 (94) defeated South Bunbury 9.3 (57) |
| 1946 Pastimes 14.16 (82) defeated South Bunbury 10.7 (77) |
| 1947 pastimes 9.9 (63) defeated South Bunbury 4.7 (31) |
| B Grade |
| 1934 Pastimes 15.19 (109) defeated South Bunbury 4.11 (35) |
| 1936 Pastimes 7.5 (47) defeated Elgin 3.10 (28) |
| 1946 Pastimes 13.6 (84) defeated South Bunbury 8.6 (54) |
As Carey Park Football Club
| 1963 | |||
| Sunday 29th September | |||
| Carey Park 11.11 (77) defeated Busselton 10.16 (76) | |||
| COACH: | Ray Pickering | ||
| B: | Maurie Salmon | Ron Yates | Ozzie Hardy |
| H-B: | Neville Hoskins | Rob Nielsen | Eric Christian |
| C: | Gordon Bazzo | Ray Pickering | Robin Clarke |
| H-F: | Michael Bridges | David Moyes | Brian Lawrence |
| F: | Bill Warburton | Phil Prosser | Roy Criddle |
| FOLL: | Barry John | John Haley | John Martinson |
| RES: | Clem Penninment | Bruce Daniel | |
| Match Details: | |||
| Goals: | Carey Park – Moyes 4, Lawrence 3, Martinson, Bridges, Warburton, Prosser | ||
| Busselton – Allsop 3, Pettit, Reilly, Gutheridge, Brockman, Pross, Smith, Hunter | |||
| Pike Medalist: | Brian Pross (Busselton) | ||
| 1973 | |||
| Sunday 30th September | |||
| Carey Park 10.9 (69) defeated Harvey-Brunswick 8.10 (58) | |||
| COACH: | Brian Sarre | ||
| B: | Brian Sarre | Rob Carlson | Kevin Waters |
| H-B: | Jim Sharpe | Errol Barrett | Graeme Carlson |
| C: | Ben Neale | John Panizza | Greg Kelly |
| H-F: | Michael Johnson | Neil Lloyd | Vern King |
| F: | Mick Van Wyk | David Lightfoot | Steven Panizza |
| FOLL: | Kevin Scanlan | John Waters | John Martinson |
| RES: | Peter Lange | Dennis Wilson | |
| Match details | |||
| Goals: | Carey Park – S. Panizza 3, D. Lightfoot, J. Waters 2, N. Lloyd, J. Martinson, M. Johnson 1 | ||
| Harvey-Brunswick – G. Little, M. Olsen 2, B. Scott, B. Little, F. Sacca, M. Baggetta 1 | |||
| Pike Medalist: | Kevin Scanlan (Carey Park) | ||
| 1986 | |||
| Sunday | |||
| Carey Park 4.2 15.8 23.11 31.17 (203) defeated Collie 5.5 7.6 9.11 14.11 (95) | |||
| COACH: | Merv Kennedy | ||
| CAPTAIN: | Shaun O’Callaghan | ||
| B: | Frank Lawler | Michael Lane | Steven Stewart |
| H-B: | Steven Sharp | Leigh Brenton | Malcolm Cooke |
| C: | Murray Collard | Troy Ugle | Shaun O’Callaghan |
| H-F: | Stan Willis | Russell Waterman | Steven Bazzo |
| F: | Michael Dye | Kurnutt Thone | Tony Walters |
| FOLL: | Leigh Wright | Graeme Carlson | Mark Skehan |
| I/C: | Tony Monaco | Michael Martinson | |
| Match details: | |||
| Goals: | Carey Park – K. Thorne 7, M. Skehan, R. Waterman 5, S. O’Callaghan, S. Willis 3, T. Ugle, M. Martinson 2, S. Bazzo, S. Stewart, M. Cook, G. Carlson 1 | ||
| Collie – D. Hollins 4, I. Massara, A. White, K. Hayward 2, N. Jackson, P. Carpenter, D. O’Brien, G. O’Brien 1 | |||
| Pike Medalist: | Troy Ugle (Carey Park) | ||
| 2003 | |||
| Sunday 5th October | |||
| Carey Park 4.1 9.3 14.3 16.7 (103) defeated South Bunbury 3.3 7.5 8.8 11.11 (77) | |||
| COACH: | Geoff Nitschke | ||
| CAPTAIN: | Richard Barnard | ||
| B: | Corey Stidworthy | Richard Barnard | Shane Jones |
| H-B: | Craig Hall | Garrod Delfs | Adam Linforth |
| C: | Peter Jetta | Stan Willis | Wayne Thackrah |
| H-F: | Steven Pendleton | Brendan Barnard | Brendan Carlson |
| F: | Sean Widdeson | Rhys Croxford | Arron Hill |
| FOLL: | Aaron Depiazzi | James McRae | Adrian Dohnt |
| I/C: | Brendan King | Darren Sprigg | Kane Nitschke |
| Match details | |||
| Goals: | Carey Park – P. Jetta 4, A. Hill 3, S. Pendleton, B. Barnard, A. Dohnt, K. Nitschke 2, J. McRae 1 | ||
| South Bunbury – W. Hughes 3, D. Buswell 2, P. Bird, M. Pell, S. Bilcich, B. Maloney, J. Stephens, A. White 1 | |||
| Pike Medalist: | James McRae (Carey Park) | ||
| 2006 | ||||
| Sunday 8th October | ||||
| Carey Park 3.3 4.8 8.12 10.13 (73) defeated Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault 0.7 5.12 7.15 8.21 (69) | ||||
| COACH: | Crandon Keddie | |||
| CAPTAIN: | Richard Barnard | |||
| B: | Jamie Nani | Richard Barnard | Nathan Reeve | |
| H-B: | Jake O’Mara | Cam Venables | Shane Cooke | |
| C: | Cody Garlett | Steven Pendleton | Peter Jetta | |
| H-F: | James McRae | Greg Atkinson | Chris Denney | |
| F: | Travis Daniels | Shane Nani | Graham Jetta | |
| FOLL: | Travis Edmonds | Tim Nelli | Corey Tomsett | |
| I/C: | Jy King | Arron Hill | Donald Turvey | Shannon Spadaccini |
| Match details | ||||
| Goals: | Carey Park – S. Nani 2, P. Jetta 2, T. Nelli 2, T. Daniels 2, J. King, G. Atkinson 1 | |||
| Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault – M. Sherry 3, K. Williams 1, L. Hogan 1, D. Newman 1, D. Wilson 1, S. Wescombe 1 | ||||
| Pike Medalist: | ||||
| 2008 | ||||
| Sunday 5th October | ||||
| Carey Park 3.2 10.4 17.8 18.12 (120) Defeated Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault 6.0 8.0 9.2 14.8 (92) | ||||
| COACH: | John Baggetta | |||
| CAPTAIN: | Shane Nani | |||
| B: | Corey Tomsett | Damien Gaspar | Tristan MacMillan | |
| H-B: | Charles Tallent | Bryce Willday | Tom Collins | |
| C: | Viv Blurton | Scott Roche | Jamie Bennell | |
| H-F: | Clinton Garlett | Michael McMillan | Travis Daniels | |
| F: | Arron Hill | Shane Nani | Frank Quartermaine | |
| FOLL: | Dan Atkinson | Ryan Clough | Justin Wilson | |
| I/C: | Kurt Hinkley | Jake O’Mara | Garrod Delfs | James Sebire |
| Match details | ||||
| Goals: | Carey Park – S. Nani 6, K. Hinkley 2. S. Roche 2, A. Hill 2, J. Bennell 2, F. Quartermaine 1, J. Wilson 1, V. Blurton 1, M. McMillan 1 | |||
| Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault – K. Williams 4, M. Sherry 3, D. Newman 2, R. McFarland 1, T. Gleadell 1, A. Morabito 1, N. Elari 1, D. Lewis 1 | ||||
| Pike Medalist: | Justin Wilson (CP) | |||
| 2009 | ||||
| Sunday 20th September | ||||
| Carey Park 2.1 4.2 8.5 8.7 (55) defeated South Bunbury 1.3 3.5 3.6 4.9 (33) | ||||
| COACH: | John Baggetta | |||
| CAPTAIN: | Shane Nani | |||
| B: | Glen Garlett | James Sebire | Shannon Spadaccini | |
| H-B: | Tom Collins | Damien Gaspar | Cody Garlett | |
| C: | Kirk Ugle | Scott Roche | Travis McGuire | |
| H-F: | Liam McGuire | Michael McMillan | Jake O’Mara | |
| F: | Arron Hill | Shane Nani | Viv Blurton | |
| FOLL: | Michael Finn | Brendan Carlson | Matt Virgo | |
| I/C: | Chris Rintoul | Corey Tomsett | Chris McMillan | Peter Jetta |
| Match Details | ||||
| Goals: | Carey Park – M. Virgo 2, T. McGuire 2, C. Garlett 1, L. McGuire 2, K. Ugle 1 | |||
| South Bunbury – R. Mackenzie 2, R. Pegararo 1, N. Fielding 1 | ||||
| Pike Medalist: | Scott Roche (Carey Park) | |||
| Reserves |
| 1963 Carey Park 8.9 (57) defeated South Bunbury 7.13 (55) |
| 1970 Carey Park 12.12 (84) defeated Augusta-Margaret River 6.6 (42) |
| 1978 Carey Park 10.8 (68) defeated Donnybrook 5.10 (40) |
| 1979 Carey Park 17.6 (118) defeated South Bunbury 12.12 (84) |
| 1982 Carey Park 18.9 (117) defeated Bunbury 14.11 (95) |
| 1985 Carey Park 21.14 (140) defeated South Bunbury 11.7 (73) |
| 1988 Carey Park 17.6 (108) defeated Bunbury 10.10 (70) |
| 2001 Carey Park 14.10 (94) defeated Harvey-Brunswick-Leschenault 8.4 (52) |
| 2014 Carey Park 9.12 (60) defeated South Bunbury 5.7 (37) |
| Colts |
| 1963 Carey Park 12.11 (83) defeated South Bunbury 10.10 (70) |
| 1981 Carey Park 11.20 (86) defeated Harvey-Brunswick 8.6 (54) |
| 1985 Carey Park 12.11 (87 defeated Harvey-Brunswick 4.7 (31) |
| 1987 Carey Park 12.6 (78) defeated Donnybrook 9.12 (66) |
| 1988 Carey Park 17.10 (112) defeated Mines Rovers 11.7 (73) |
| 1989 Carey Park 12.14 (86) defeated Bunbury 6.3 (39) |
| 2008 Carey Park 11.7 (73) defeated Eaton Boomers 10.12 (72) |
| 2010 Carey Park 9.10 (64) defeated Eaton Boomers 7.16 (58) |
| 2021 Carey Park 8.12 (60) defeated Busselton 8.4 (52) |
| 2022 Carey Park 16.9 (105) defeated Bunbury 6.7 (43) |